I had a friend once called Emma. And yes, that’s her real name. I use it because it is unlikely she reads this blog.
One day Emma was talking about her then-boyfriend, about some argument they had had or some such. I can’t remember the story, mainly because they had a tempestuous relationship and their fights were non-stop.
However, one thing that Emma said to me that I’ve never forgotten, because it’s bugged me all this time. She said to me, “He should just love me unconditionally.”
Well, yes.
And no.
As with everything, there’s a for and against to this statement.
YES:
- unconditional love denotes acceptance for the person just the way they are
- unconditional love does not put undue pressure on someone to change or conform to someone else’s ideal image
- unconditional love makes people feel loved and valued for who they are and can just be themselves
- unconditional love is to love someone regardless of their beliefs or actions or values
NO:
- unconditional love runs the risk of accepting unacceptable behaviour in others
- unconditional love means there’s no constructive criticism for someone to become a better person
- unconditional love might allow an abusive partner to get away with being abusive
- unconditional love may implicitly (or explicitly) condone hateful and/or dangerous beliefs or actions or values
- disagreeing with the concept of unconditional love doesn’t mean you lose faith in people; faith and unconditional love are different things
As it so happens, I had an argument with a friend tonight about something which ended with me being (quite rightly) chastened with the comment, “How about you just not mouthing off when you disagree with me?”
Yeah. I accept that one. I did mouth off before I realised I was doing it, for two reasons:
- I sometimes tend to be controlling. It’s been a long time realising that and just as long accepting that, but I agree. Instead of just accepting, I try to change the situation or change someone’s mind or somehow just control things as I see fit
- I genuinely and strongly disagreed about something my friend and I were talking about and damned if I wasn’t going to say something
That’s the conundrum. How much unconditional love do I give (i.e. accepting my friend’s decision and not shoot my mouth off just because I disagree) and how much do I stand up and say something before my friend does something potentially risky? Because what if I didn’t sound those warning bells and sometime down the track, with hindsight, I should have?
How far do we go in not saying anything to those we love and letting them learn from their mistakes and how far do we go before we should say something?
How much can two friends disagree and when can those disagreements be aired? After all, a friendship (or relationship) is not about agreeing on every single thing. How boring would that be! Sometimes unconditional love needs to be conditional if we are to be true friends and give a different perspective or point out things that they can’t see or recognise. This is true because we often can’t see things in ourselves that others can. This is especially true if friends are engaged in self-destructive behaviour. We don’t want them to self-destruct or sabotage their lives; that’s why we speak up and speak vehemently and love them while telling them that their behaviour is not acceptable.
Isn’t it?
What’s a friendship worth if you can’t disagree every now and then and be allowed to debate why?
As friends or lovers or family members, don’t we have an obligation to “mouth off” when you genuinely think they’re making a mistake or about to make one?
Then again, life is about making mistakes and people learning from them. So just how far do we “warn” them?
And, of course, what if our misgivings turn out to be nothing but hot air? I’ve had people warn me not to do this and not to do that with their warnings turning out to be hot air. A part of me afterwards felt they were being silly and overly cautious and so the next time I took their warnings less seriously. They were wrong once, chances are they’ll be wrong again. Right?
After tonight’s argument, I realise that my problem is that I sometimes argue too harshly. I get exasperated and practically scornful, all because I disagree oh-so-strongly. I’m an argumentive person anyway, that’s not going to change. I don’t want to feel like I have to shut up just to keep people happy, and I’m definitely not going to shut up when I firmly believe a friend or a family member or a lover is about to do something potentially destructive or are behaving in an unacceptable way. (Likewise, I want my people to point out my shortcomings to me and while I hate hearing certain things — ah, ego is a bitch — I’m glad for it. I know I can be mouthy or pushy or controlling and I need to hear it because I don’t always see it.)
I know now I need to modify how I disagree with someone with respect and not pushing the fucking point when they’ve clearly had enough of it. I know how annoying it is when people tell me what I should or shouldn’t do after I’ve heard what they’ve had to say but they persist in labouring the point, perhaps in vain hope that I might crack and agree with them. Not gonna happen! It just makes me dig my heels in deeper.
However, I’ve had people tell me that I’m too controlling or, put a better way, attempt to control things instead of letting life and fate take its natural course. It stems in part from my inherent anxiety — if I can’t control something, I get anxious and that includes with people, especially with people I care about.
So, more things for me to learn:
- when to accept that I should not say anything when I disagree and shut the hell up
- when to verbally disagree (and whether the thing I disagree with is worth being vocal about)
- disagree a bit more respectfully instead of getting hot tempered and exasperated
- learn when to just drop the argument
- accept that some people might just not want to hear what you have to say for whatever reason, so stop talking
- accept that people have to make their own choices and decisions; if they make a mistake it doesn’t mean they’re stupid but, rather, learning and growing. I’m going to be making a lot of mistakes for the rest of my life too — and I will need to if I am to grow
That, to me, is unconditional love — with caveats attached.
Recent Comments